Site Navigation

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
News
FAQ

Deer Accounting

"Over 40 Years of Experience"

About Us

Located in Greencastle, Indiana, Deer Accounting has proudly served the community since 1985. As a locally owned business, we specialize in tax services, bookkeeping, payroll, and more. With over 40 years of experience, Greencastle's business owners, farmers, and residents trust us to deliver precise financial solutions. We're committed to accommodating your busy schedule with Saturday appointments available. Reach out to us today for reliable and dedicated service!

Our Story

Deer Accounting, located in Greencastle, IN, is your trusted partner for tax preparation, bookkeeping, and payroll services. We specialize in providing personalized financial solutions for individuals and small businesses, ensuring our clients can focus on what matters most to them—whether that’s growing their business or spending time with family.

Founded by Tiffany, Deer Accounting began with a desire to create a workplace and business that prioritizes flexibility and family. After starting her career in human resources, Tiffany realized that the lack of work-life balance in the field wasn’t conducive to her goals. Determined to make a change, she launched Deer Accounting to not only pursue her dream of being her own boss but also to provide the same flexibility and balance for her team. Today, this family-focused approach extends to her clients, making every interaction feel like part of a community.

At Deer Accounting, we understand that managing finances can be time-consuming and stressful. Our mission is to handle the complexities of financial management so our clients can concentrate on their priorities. Our services include tax preparation for both individuals and businesses, bookkeeping designed for small business needs, and payroll solutions that streamline operations and save time. By taking care of these essential tasks, we empower our clients to focus on what they value most.

One of the things that sets Deer Accounting apart is our commitment to treating everyone like family. As a small-town business, we value personal relationships and strive to understand each client’s unique needs. This allows us to provide tailored services and deliver the respect and attention our clients deserve. We believe in fostering trust and building partnerships that go beyond numbers.

Clients can expect a friendly and professional experience when working with us. We take the time to get to know your individual or business needs, ensuring that our services align with your goals. Whether you need assistance with small business taxes, detailed bookkeeping, or payroll management, our team is here to support you every step of the way.

Deer Accounting also understands the importance of convenience, offering appointments on Saturdays to accommodate busy schedules. By focusing on what we do best, we enable our clients to spend their time doing what they love. Whether it’s growing a business, enjoying family time, or pursuing personal passions, we make it possible for our clients to prioritize what matters most.

At Deer Accounting, our goal is to provide expert financial services with the warmth and care of a close-knit community. Let us handle the numbers so you can focus on what truly counts.

Areas Served

Putnam County, IN | Greencastle, IN

Our Professional Associations

Rotary Club
State of Indiana Sheep Association

Our Certifications

Accounting Practitioner
CPA
Enrolled Agent
IRS Certified

What We Offer

Our Services include:

Tax Preparation
Bookkeeping
Small Business Taxes
Notary
Available Saturdays by Appointment Only

Testimonials

On 4/16/2026 Mary Catherine A. had this to say:
Great group of people. Very knowledgeable about tax preparation. Quick service, very dependable

On 4/9/2026 Joe & Karla Lawless had this to say:
Great company. Ladies are wo derdul at the front window, personable and pleasant. We are very pleased with deer Accounting. Always completed in a timely fashion and is always there to answer any questions we..ight have..would highly recommend them. Testimonial written by Joe & Karla Lawless on this site.

On 3/24/2026 Debra Pollpeter had this to say:
Appreciate Tiffany & her team’s responsiveness and professionalism!

On 4/21/2025 Anonymous had this to say:
Tiffany and her staff have always been professional, kind, and quick to reply to any questions or concerns I had. Testimonial submitted anonymously directly to this site.

On 4/19/2025 Brad Laney had this to say:
Deer Accounting has been great to us, not only for my business but also my personal accounts. Tiffany is very knowledgeable and detail oriented with all of the complicated work that comes along with completing business taxes such as depreciation, mileage, percentages on certain expenses, etc. Each year, she provides us a very well organized & detailed return. She is always willing to answer my questions on the phone any time but also via emails. Sometimes it’s hard to tell a person’s “tone” in an email but with her I always get friendly, detailed and positive responses.

Contact Us

Deer Accounting
110 W Walnut Greencastle, IN 46135
Phone: (765) 653-6825
Fax: (765) 653-9973
Email: info@deeraccounting.com

Located in Historic Greencastle. Across from DePauw University

Where To Find Us

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

News

🎃🍁 October is here, and it's the perfect time to get ahead before year-end! 🍁🎃

The final quarter of the year is a great opportunity to review your finances, organize important records, and prepare for tax season before the holiday rush begins. Whether you need help with bookkeeping, payroll, or tax planning, Deer Accounting is here to provide trusted, local support backed by over 40 years of experience serving Greencastle and the surrounding communities.

Don't wait until December to get your finances in order. Let our experienced team help you finish the year strong and with confidence. 📊✅

📍 110 W Walnut St, Greencastle, IN

#DeerAccounting #OctoberTips #FinancialPlanning #BookkeepingServices #PayrollSolutions #TaxPreparation #GreencastleIN #SmallBusinessSupport #FallFinance #LocalExperts

As the leaves fall, it's the perfect time to tidy up your finances! 🍁

October is a great month to review bookkeeping records, organize receipts, and prepare for year-end tax planning. Let Deer Accounting help you stay organized and stress-free before the busy holiday season begins.

✅ Bookkeeping Services
✅ Payroll Support
✅ Tax Planning Guidance

📍 Greencastle, IN
📞 Call today to schedule an appointment!

#DeerAccounting #GreencastleIN #BookkeepingServices #FinancialPlanning #SmallBusinessAccounting #FallFinance

For more than four decades, Deer Accounting has proudly helped individuals, businesses, and farmers navigate their financial needs with confidence. From tax preparation and bookkeeping to payroll services, our dedicated team provides personalized service and dependable solutions tailored to you.

Don't wait until tax season to get organized. Start preparing now and enjoy greater peace of mind throughout the year.

📞 Contact Deer Accounting today to learn how we can help.

✅ Focus on your business. We'll handle payroll.

Running a business comes with enough responsibilities. Let Deer Accounting take payroll off your plate with reliable, accurate payroll services designed to save you time and reduce stress. Our experienced team works closely with local businesses to ensure employees are paid correctly and on time.

This September, give your business the support it deserves.

📍 110 W Walnut St, Greencastle, IN

Managing your finances doesn’t have to be complicated. At Deer Accounting, we provide professional tax services, bookkeeping, and payroll support designed to simplify your workload and keep your records accurate year‑round.
Whether you’re preparing for tax season, balancing your books, or running payroll for your business, our experienced team works closely with you to deliver reliable results and peace of mind. We understand that schedules are busy, which is why we focus on efficiency, flexibility, and clear guidance every step of the way.
Our services include:
✔ Individual & business tax preparation
✔ Payroll services
✔ Bookkeeping & financial organization
✔ Friendly, knowledgeable local support
📍 Proudly serving Greencastle and surrounding Indiana communities
👉 Contact us today and let Deer Accounting handle the numbers

FAQ

What services does Deer Accounting offer?

We provide a full range of financial services including tax preparation, bookkeeping, small business taxes, and payroll solutions. Our goal is to make managing your finances simple, accurate, and stress-free.

How long has Deer Accounting been serving the Greencastle community?

Deer Accounting has proudly served Greencastle, Indiana, and the surrounding communities since 1985 — offering over 40 years of trusted experience in personalized accounting and tax services.

Do you work with both individuals and businesses?

Yes! We assist individuals, families, farmers, and small business owners with customized tax and bookkeeping solutions tailored to their unique financial needs.

Are appointments available outside of regular business hours?

Absolutely. We understand busy schedules — that’s why we offer Saturday appointments by request to make it easier for you to get the financial help you need.

How can I schedule an appointment with Deer Accounting?

You can reach out to us directly by phone or email to book an appointment. We recommend scheduling ahead, especially during tax season, to secure your preferred time.